Search Incident Rule for Vehicles “Narrowed”

Today, 4/21/09, The United States Supreme Court severely narrowed the common reading of New York v. Belton, 433 U.S. 454 (1981) allowing officers to search the vehicle and its contents of an arrestee as a search incident to a lawful arrest. As the story goes, Rodney Joseph Gant was arrested on a tip for driving with a suspended license. He was then cuffed and locked in the back of a patrol car. Gant’s car was then searched and  a gun and drugs were recovered from his car for which Gant was prosecuted. At the suppression hearing, when Officer Griffith was asked why he searched the car he responded : “Because the law says we can do it.” But alas today the Court, in an opinion by our own Justice Stevens joined by Scalia, Souter,Thomas, and Ginsberg {the 4th amendment makes strange bedfellows!} held otherwise. The Court states:
“Police may search a vehicle incident to a recent occupant’s arrest only if the arrestee is within reaching distance of the passenger compartment at the time of the search or it is reasonable to believe the vehicle contains evidence of the offense of arrest”
Read all about it by cutting and pasting this link:
http://www.supremecourtus.gov/opinions/08pdf/07-542.pdf
This entry was posted in Hot Legal Topics. Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.
  • http://www.keglawyers.com/blog Joe

    You know, I’m all for preserving the freedoms that this country offers, but this just seems like making a police officer’s job that much more difficult.

  • Winona Agbabiaka

    I am sure you would not feel that way if the police officer were arresting you or someone you know.

  • Dan Walsh

    Thank you Winona.

  • Michelle Thomas

    Since when was making a cops job easy a part of the constitution? Just because they keep Dunkin Donuts in business doesn’t mean they don’t have REAL work to do….

  • stu smith

    I don’t see it as making the job harder. Now the cop, as before, arrests someone, puts him in the police car and drives away. The cop no longer has to go to the now empty car, look in the glove box, under the seats, the engine compartment, go through the garbage in the back seat, look through the trunk, lift the floor mats in the trunk, examine the spare tire and on before transporting the arrestee. This will free up police time for other things including donuts.

  • Stephanie S.

    I guess I can leave my contraband in my glove box now.

  • Bruce Mosbacher

    Red wine is not contraband unless its opened Stephanie.